[New York's Shake Shack] A Detailed Menu Guide & Classic Food Review

When it comes to New York's culinary scene, you certainly can't miss the East Coast's burger titan, Shake Shack! From humble beginnings as a hot dog cart, it has grown into an internationally recognized fast-food chain. But what makes it so delicious? The impeccable American burgers, crispy fries, and abundant milkshakes have captured food enthusiasts' hearts worldwide. In this article, we delve into Shake Shack in New York's Madison Square Park, offering a highly detailed introduction to their diverse menu - all you need to understand the different burgers.

Table of Contents

Overview (Madison Square Park)

Address: 23rd Street and, Madison Square Park, Madison Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA

Google Map：Link

Hours: Daily 10:00 – 23:30

Tel:212-889-6600

Official Website：Link - You also can order online!

The Origin of Shake Shack

Shake Shack originated in 2001 when New York City restaurateur Danny Meyer organized an art event, the "Madison Square Park Conservancy’s first art installation." A hot dog cart in the installation proved immensely popular, leading Meyer to establish a permanent food stand dedicated to these treats.

In 2004, Meyer opened the first Shake Shack in Madison Square Park, expanding the menu to include burgers, milkshakes, and ice cream. The restaurant's name harks back to the roadside diners of the 1950s, representing a sense of community and warmth for people.

Over time, Shake Shack's reputation and popularity continued to soar, attracting more and more food lovers. In 2008, Shake Shack opened its second location in the Upper East Side of NYC. Since then, Shake Shack has continued to expand across the U.S. and worldwide, gracing cities in the Middle East, Asia, and Europe, earning the title of "East Coast's burger titan."

Travel Review!

We visited on a bright weekday afternoon, and while there were quite a few people, it wasn't overly crowded. The line wasn't too long, just about three or four people waiting.

We ordered two burgers (highly recommended!), two orders of fries, and two milkshakes (really rich and thick). One order of fries was unsalted - you can ask the staff for any customization you need! After all, New York food tends to be salty. Ketchup and napkins were available for self-service.

The menu is coming up! Scroll down for an ultra-detailed introduction to it!! Understand exactly what each burger is all about.

As is usual in fast food, tipping isn't required but is accepted if you'd like to. You'll be notified when your order is ready either by a buzzer or by a member of staff calling out your name (quite literally shouting "XX, where are you?" and the likes).

Visiting at night offers a beautiful view as well.

A Parade of Pups

Madison Square Park truly has an array of dogs, large and small, making their way around, showcasing the constant canine presence in New York!

The distinguished poodle waiting in line!!

The curious poodle taking in its surroundings...

The well-mannered Border Collie...

The pair of obedient little white dogs walking nicely...

Detailed Introduction to the Menu in English!

Beef Burgers

All burgers can be doubled up with two beef patties!

ShackBurger™: The classic burger! Comprised of Angus beef, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and ShackSauce, all placed within a toasted potato roll, it's simplicity at its delicious best. Bourbon Bacon Jam Burger: Made with 100% Angus beef and cheese, topped with crispy onions and a drizzle of ShackSauce and Maker’s Mark Bourbon Bacon Jam. This unique combination of flavors provides an unparalleled culinary delight.
Bourbon Bacon Jam Burger: Made with 100% Angus beef and cheese, topped with crispy onions and a drizzle of ShackSauce and Maker’s Mark Bourbon Bacon Jam. This unique combination of flavors provides an unparalleled culinary delight.
SmokeShack™: The classic smoked burger! Includes Angus beef, cheese, applewood smoked bacon, chopped cherry pepper, and ShackSauce, all inside a toasted potato bun. Rich in flavors, unique, and delicious.
Avocado Bacon Burger: This burger comprises Angus beef, cheese, freshly sliced avocado, applewood smoked bacon, and ShackSauce, all inside a toasted potato bun. It offers a taste of succulent meat combined with the freshness of avocado.
Shack Stack™: This is a combination of an Angus cheeseburger and a ’Shroom Burger! Complete with lettuce, tomato, and ShackSauce on a toasted potato roll. It offers a rich taste where meaty flavor and mushroom essence perfectly blend.
Hamburger: Just a simple Angus beef burger, but you can choose to add any toppings to suit your taste.
Cheeseburger: Angus beef with cheese, and your choice of toppings.
Bacon Cheeseburger: This burger is made with Angus beef and cheese, topped with applewood smoked bacon, all inside a toasted potato bun. The rich aroma of the meat and smoky flavor are unforgettable.

Please note for allergies! Many burgers contain sesame, egg, milk, soy, wheat, and gluten.

Veggie Burgers

‘Shroom Burger: A veggie burger featuring a crispy fried Portobello mushroom filled with melted muenster and cheddar cheeses, topped with lettuce, tomato, and ShackSauce spread on a grilled potato bun.
Veggie Shack™: Another veggie option containing mushrooms, sweet potatoes, carrots, whole grains, and quinoa, topped with American cheese, crispy onions, pickles, and ShackSauce. This burger offers a rich array of flavors and textures that will leave you wanting more.

Chicken Burgers

Chicken Shack™: A burger featuring crispy-fried chicken breast with a juicy texture. It also includes fresh lettuce, sweet and sour pickles, and a layer of creamy buttermilk herb mayo, all served on a grilled potato bun.
Avocado Bacon Chicken: A chicken burger with freshly sliced avocado, smoked applewood bacon, lettuce, pickles, and buttermilk herb mayo. The soft texture of the avocado, salty bacon, and crispy chicken breast form a perfect combination.
Chicken Bites™: Bite-sized pieces of white chicken meat deep-fried to a crisp exterior and tender inside. They are paired with either honey mustard sauce or barbecue sauce, allowing you to choose according to your preference.

Toppings

Do you want to add extras or customize your own burger? Here are some options:

Pickles
Tomato
Lettuce
Red Onion
Peppers
Cheese (For Example, American Cheese / Cheddar)
Bacon
Special sauces like Shack Sauce
Smoked bacon sauce
Mushroom
Avocado
Sautéed Onion

Fries

Spicy Fries with Ranch: Crispy fries seasoned with a unique spicy chili mix, giving each fry its unique kick. Served with our homemade ranch-style sauce as a dip, which provides an extra layer of taste and texture.
Spicy Cheese Fries with Ranch: Spicy cheese fries are an upgraded version of the spicy fries, with the addition of cheese sauce. Crispy fries are drizzled with creamy cheese sauce, seasoned with our exclusive chili seasoning, delivering a rich taste experience for your palate. Also served with ranch sauce.
Fries: Classic fries, golden and crispy, suitable for everyone.
Cheese Fries: Classic fries topped with cheese sauce, adding a rich dairy flavor. Please note, these fries contain soy and dairy.
Bacon Cheese Fries: Luxury fries! On the base of Cheese Fries, we've added applewood smoked bacon, with a subtle smoky flavor that perfectly balances the richness of the cheese.

Milkshakes & Custards

What is Frozen Custard? A very rich, smooth ice cream product made primarily of egg yolks, sugar, and cream. Compared to regular ice cream, frozen custard usually contains a higher proportion of egg yolks and cream, resulting in a richer and smoother texture.

At Shake Shack, they freshly prepare frozen custard daily, and all their milkshakes are made from frozen cream!

OREO Cookie Funnel Cake Shake: A shake that combines the crunchy texture of OREO cookies and funnel cake, mixed with vanilla frozen custard, topped with chocolate mousse. You can also add colorful sprinkles to support PFLAG.
Triple Chocolate Brownie Shake: A shake based on chocolate frozen custard and brownie chunks, with chocolate chips and chocolate beans, topped with whipped cream and brownie crumbs. A dream choice for chocolate lovers. You can also add colorful sprinkles to support PFLAG.
Non-Dairy Chocolate Shake: A shake suitable for customers who do not consume dairy products. Made with NotMilk™ to create a plant-based chocolate frozen custard, hand-stirred.
Non-Dairy Chocolate Frozen Custard: This custard is also made with NotMilk™, with a smooth texture that is popular among vegetarians.
Vanilla / Chocolate Shake: Classic vanilla shake / chocolate shake.
Cookies and Cream Shake: A shake that combines chocolate cookie crumbs and vanilla frozen custard, hand-stirred. The texture is both crunchy and smooth.
Strawberry Shake: A shake made of real strawberries and homemade vanilla frozen custard, hand-stirred, with a rich strawberry flavor and milky aroma.
Black & White Shake: A homemade vanilla frozen custard plus chocolate syrup, hand-stirred. It has a rich vanilla and chocolate flavor.
Vanilla & Chocolate Shake: A perfect combination of homemade vanilla and chocolate frozen custard. You can taste the sweetness of vanilla and the richness of chocolate.
Floats: Soda milkshakes! They come in two flavors, Root Beer and Creamsicle®. Both are topped with their homemade frozen custard, making them refreshing, unique, and creative.
Frozen Custard: Vanilla and chocolate frozen custard is made in-store daily. It is smooth, sweet, and delicious. You can order it straight up!

Hot Dogs

Even though they started with hot dogs, it seems like their burgers are more popular!

Shack-cago Dog: This signature hot dog is made from 100% pure beef from Chicago's Vienna® Beef. It's topped with pickles, onions, cucumbers, tomatoes, sport peppers, celery salt, and mustard.
Hot Dog: The regular hot dog is also made from 100% pure beef from Chicago's Vienna® Beef. Simple yet packed with flavors, it's a classic choice.

Drinks

Strawberry Lemonade: This lemonade is based on real strawberries and homemade lemon juice. It's a perfect blend of sour and sweet, and you can choose a caffeinated version.
Dragonfruit Pomegranate Lemonade: This lemonade combines real dragon fruit and pomegranate with homemade lemon juice.
Mango Passionade: This lemonade is a blend of real mango and passion fruit with homemade lemon juice, sour and sweet with a tropical twist.
Shack-made Lemonade: This homemade lemonade is made from real lemon juice and cane sugar, perfectly sour and sweet, an ideal choice for cooling off.
Fifty/Fifty™ Lemonades: This drink is a half-and-half combination of any of the lemonades above and organic cold-brewed tea, offering a unique, refreshing taste.
Organic Iced Tea: This iced tea is freshly brewed daily from Harney & Sons organic tea. It has a refreshing taste and a subtle tea aroma, an ideal choice for quenching your thirst in the summer.
Fountain Soda: Standard sodas of various flavors, including Coca Cola, Diet Coke, Dr Pepper, Fanta Orange, Sprite, Ginger Ale, and Coca-Cola Zero Sugar. These beverages are classic fast food drinks.

Conclusion

From tasting the classic ShackBurger, exploring the vegetarian 'Shroom Burger, to trying their signature milkshakes, you'll find that the charm of Shake Shack lies in their passion and expertise in food. And the store located in Madison Square Park even further highlights this charm! Paired with the beautiful scenery and lively atmosphere of the park, the food tastes even better. So, the next time you're in New York, take some time to sit in Shake Shack, taste their food, and experience the food culture of New York!

For more travel notes in New York, you're welcome to visit RosyArts' New York exclusive page->Link

[New York's Shake Shack] A Detailed Menu Guide & Classic Food Review | Madison Square Park